Product marketers never forget the day they first have to dive into CRM data.
Our mid-market sales team wasn’t hitting their targets, and as the product marketing lead, I was responsible for uncovering why.
I opened Salesforce, ready to find the answers that would turn our performance around.
But what I found left me slack-jawed.
Our “competitive data†fields were a wasteland. Empty cells and vague responses.
“No competition†was suspiciously common, and our win-loss reasons read like a game of Mad Libs.
So I exported the last quarter’s worth of opportunities into a spreadsheet and sent it to our reps, determined to fill in the blanks.
The results trickled in. Finally, we’d understand what was happening in our deals!
But as I stared at phrases like “team input pricing†and the oh-so-descriptive “features,†I realized we were no closer to the truth than before.
That’s when it hit me. We’d been making three critical mistakes:
- Blindly trusting our incomplete CRM data
- Accepting our sellers’ perspectives without question
- Filling in the gaps with our own assumptions
I marched into our CRO’s office, spreadsheet in hand, ready to make my case for a complete overhaul of our approach.
To my surprise, he was on board before I’d even finished my pitch.
What happened next changed everything about how we understand our deals – and it all started with one simple shift in perspective.
Let me show you how we finally got out of the dark and started winning more deals by going straight to the source: our buyers.
The dirty secret about your CRM data
Salesforce reports that 91% of CRM data is incomplete, and that 70% of this data becomes inaccurate annually.
That’s right. Your “data†is about as reliable as a magic 8-ball.

Not to mention that a majority of those deal reasons are from a drop-down list that provide minimal insight, like “budgetâ€, “no decisionâ€, or “bad timingâ€.
Responses like that drive product marketers (like Andrea below) crazy. It’s like telling a doctor to treat a patient based solely on whether they wrote “felt bad†on an intake form.
Seller deal reasons are unreliable
“But we always debrief our sales team!†you might protest.
Yes, you want the seller’s side of the story. But relying on that as gospel?
It’s biased and only gives a partial view into what really happened in a deal. In fact, 60% of sellers are partially or completely wrong about why they lost a deal.

In my case, once sellers actually filled out deal reasons, they were surface level and didn’t actually provide insight.
(We also sat down with a buyer and a seller after a deal fell apart to get the truth about what really happened below 👇)
Businesses have their buyers on mute
So, what’s left when your data’s unreliable and your sellers are off-base?
Instinct. Gut feeling. The “loudest voice in the room.â€
That’s because our data shows only 49% of revenue leaders reported that their business conducts qualitative win-loss research.

That means over half of businesses are flying blind, without directly talking to the buyers that they sell too.
In fact, Talya Heller went through that exact scenario when she previously joined a company as a product marketer.
There is light at the end of the tunnel
But there’s hope. And it comes from an obvious yet overlooked source: your buyers.
By talking directly to the decision-makers, you can bypass unreliable CRM data, sidestep sellers’ misconceptions, and cut through the fog of gut feelings.
It was the quickest and most accurate way for me to get the unvarnished truth about how we stacked up.
Your competitors might already be basking in the glow of buyer insights.
Don’t let them leave you in the dust – or more accurately, in the dark. Check out °µºÚÍø Win-Loss to learn more about getting your buyer’s side of the story.
SHARE THIS POST